The St. Croix Historic Preservation Committee (HPC) gave the green light Thursday to new construction in Christiansted and Frederiksted, aiming to strike a balance between modern development and preservation of the island’s rich architectural heritage.
During their monthly meeting on Thursday, the committee reviewed a series of proposals, each, they said, designed to enhance the functionality of historic sites while maintaining their cultural and historical integrity.
Approved unanimously was new construction at #19 and #20 Prince Street in Frederiksted. The site, which has evolved from a feed shop to a construction office, is poised for a major transformation, according to architectural designer Clarence Browne, who represented the property owners during the meeting. Browne presented plans to develop the space into a multi-functional venue, including a fitness center, an amenity entertainment space featuring games like pin bowling and a golf simulator, and a refreshment area. The upper level will house six guest rooms, complete with an outdoor deck, offering visitors a unique blend of historical ambiance and modern amenities, he said.
To facilitate these new additions, two existing utility buildings on the property, previously used for storage and laundry, will be demolished. Browne assured the committee that while the existing structure will undergo updates, including new overhead doors and louvers, the historical façade will largely remain intact. “The colors will stay the same with the exception of a fresh coat of paint,” Browne noted, emphasizing the project’s commitment to preserving the site’s historic character.
However, the committee expressed concern about the demolition’s potential impact on a nearby rubble wall, an integral part of Frederiksted’s historic landscape. After deliberation, the committee approved the demolition, ensuring that the project will proceed with care to avoid damaging the wall.
Another project that garnered attention was the proposed development at #3 and #4 Hospital Street in Christiansted. This site, also represented by Browne, is set to undergo significant changes aimed at revitalizing its historical significance. The committee, which had previously conducted a site walkthrough, discussed the plans for a new courtyard intended to better convey the site’s history. However, a proposed drive-through component of the structure raised concerns due to potential traffic congestion and height limitations that could negatively impact the area. Browne, acknowledging these concerns, agreed to reconsider the drive-through and instead preserve the site’s current state, aligning with the committee’s recommendations.
In addition to these major projects, the HPC also approved a variety of other proposals aimed at preserving and enhancing St. Croix’s historic districts. These included the approval of new signage in both Christiansted and Frederiksted, designed to complement the towns’ historical aesthetics, as well as repairs to the roof and porch deck at the Botanical Gardens.
Closing out, HPC members, including Chair Collette Burgess, Gerville Larsen, Rupert Pelle, Kurt Marsh Jr. and Sean L. Krigger, reiterated the importance of thoughtful development that respects and preserves the island’s history.
